So far in the discussion of weighted WAR, we’ve explained the weighting system itself, as well as the first adjustment to the base WAR totals, schedule length. We’ve also examined the system’s ranking of the best third basemen ever. But as we continue exploring both the system itself and the rankings it produces, there’s a question that needs to be answered: What does it mean to rank, say, the best left fielders of all time? More specifically, are we ranking players based on their value in left field alone (which I’ll call the “positional purist” approach), or are we evaluating their entire careers and using some criteria to classify that career into one position (the “whole career” approach)?
Monday, January 13, 2025
Thursday, January 9, 2025
Weighted WAR: Schedule Length Adjustment and Third Base Rankings
Resuming the discussion of the weighted WAR system, we start with (hopefully) the least controversial modification of the WAR totals from individual seasons: schedule length.
Schedule length is an obvious problem when comparing players across seasons. Fortunately, using estimates of wins provided by a player (e.g. WAR) allows for a fairly systematic approach here. If a player posts a 3-WAR season, it will have a much bigger impact on an average team over a 60-game schedule (improving winning percentage by .050) than over a 125-game schedule (.024) or a 160-game schedule (.019). But a straight-line adjustment doesn’t quite work, as the standings will generally have a wider spread after 60 games than after 160. What you’d want to do is estimate how much impact an individual win has on the standings at various schedule lengths.
Monday, January 6, 2025
Introducing Weighted WAR
The last several decades have seen a veritable explosion of baseball statistical analysis, both by fans and by actual MLB teams. One of the primary products of this effort has been Wins Above Replacement (WAR), the general estimate of the number of wins a particular player provided in comparison to a freely available substitute. The merits of WAR have been debated ad nauseam since its introduction, but its appeal is obvious; it combines all of a player’s contributions (or at least, all that we have measurements for) into a single number that allows direct comparisons between players on different teams, at different positions, or from different time periods. For all its faults, WAR at least serves as a reasonable estimate and a good place to begin discussion.
It is not, however, the end of the discussion. I have been experimenting with a series of adjustments to baseline WAR totals which I feel lead to a more reasonable overall rating of baseball players throughout history, and will be presenting both those adjustments and some of the results over a series of upcoming posts. The adjustment I started with is a method of combining peak and career value into one number.
Thursday, March 23, 2017
Melog Rankings: Post-Indian Wells 2017
Everyone knows the big story: Roger Federer sat out the last six months of 2016, then came back to start this year and has won the two biggest events played to date. Which is marvelous theater, of course, but it's accompanied by so many other things that I'm reluctant to discuss them in too much detail before we get to the numbers. So let's do that.
Monday, January 30, 2017
Melog Rankings: Post-Australian Open 2017
One month later, two of the members of the Big Four absorbed early, shocking upsets in Melbourne, while the other two faced off in the final of the season's first Grand Slam, with the winner overcoming a long-standing, well-known head-to-head disadvantage. If that description had been provided to anyone before the event began, it would have been expected that Murray had finally bested Djokovic and claimed his first Australian Open crown.
Instead, it was Federer and Nadal facing off in their first Grand Slam final in almost six years - a remarkable match that more than lived up to the hype (and easily justified my decision to wake up at 2:30 AM to watch it live). Federer's victory, rallying from a break deficit in the fifth set, gives him an 18th Grand Slam title. We'll cover the historical ramifications of said title when we update Grand Slam Scores in a later post, but for now, how does this affect his standing in the shorter-view Melog ratings?
Monday, November 21, 2016
Melog Rankings: Post-Finals 2016
Tennis is different. While it has its own version of the playoffs, taking the top 8 players of the year and matching them up with each other in the World Tour Finals, it does not automatically designate the winner of that event to be the champion of the year. Instead, the World Number One is the player who performed best through the grind of the ten-month tennis season.
That designation is often secured very early - in 2015, for instance, Novak Djokovic clinched the top spot by winning the US Open in early September. Through the first half of the 2016 season, it looked like we'd have another blowout, as Djokovic won the first two Slams of the year, and three of the first five Masters. After he wrapped up the French Open title (completing the career Slam, and making him the first player in nearly 50 years to hold all four Slams at once), his lead in the 2016 points race was over 3000.
And after that... well, after that, Andy Murray had the run of his life, winning seven titles from nine events stretching from Queen's Club to Paris. Djokovic won only one title in that span, and entering the World Finals, Murray held the #1 spot by a margin of just over 400 points - a gap that could easily be closed using the points available in the Finals.
The event played out perfectly, as Djokovic and Murray both swept their round robin groups and won their semifinal matches, bringing up a first in tennis history: the last match of the Tour Finals would result in the year-end #1 ranking being awarded to the winner, whichever player that was.
Murray won the match, and the title, and the year-end #1 ranking. And given how the Melog ratings have looked during the last couple of updates, the top of the upcoming table should come as little surprise...
Thursday, November 10, 2016
2016 MLB Postseason: The statistical view
It's been just over a week and it still hasn't fully sunk in. But I'll try to cut through the haze of post-title bliss and be as rational as possible in breaking down what the numbers have to say about the highly memorable 2016 postseason.