Monday, November 16, 2026

Hall of Merit: Position Player Adjustments (Part 1)

Last time, we introduced the Hall of Merit and its voting process. This time, let’s talk about how I’m modifying my original Weighted WAR rankings for use in the HoM context. We’ll start with the two most significant adjustments to the Weighted WAR system, which conveniently hearken back to two of the earliest posts in the original series that introduced the system in question.

Before we shake things up, let’s cover the things that aren’t changing. The schedule length adjustment remains the same. Negative seasons are still removed from the calculation. Pitching value is still ignored, not because it shouldn’t count but because there are no significant hybrid players up for consideration at present. (There is that one guy who’s currently active, but I suspect that by the time he’s eligible for the HoM there won’t be much need to do detail work on his candidacy.)

Negro League seasons are treated the same… sort of. The HoM electorate has done a great deal of work examining NeL players in contexts not currently recognized as official by MLB, including games played by independent teams, non-league games played by NeL teams, and Mexican and Cuban league play. On its most recent ballot, however, the HoM only had one Negro League player (Don Newcombe) in the top 40, and even Newcombe only spent two years in the Negro Leagues before joining the Dodgers. I am willing to more closely examine other NeL candidates as needed, but at present, it appears I can afford not to put more work into this topic.

With those notes in mind, here are the top 20 position players by original recipe Weighted WAR who retired in 2021 or earlier and have not yet been inducted into the HoM:

Rank

Player

Position

WtWAR

1

John Olerud

1B

43.8

2

Chet Lemon

CF

43.7

3

Dustin Pedroia

2B

43.0

4

Robin Ventura

3B

42.6

5

Jason Giambi

1B

42.6

6

Willie Davis

CF

42.4

7

Ian Kinsler

2B

42.2

8

Cesar Cedeno

CF

42.1

9

Ron Cey

3B

41.7

10

Kirby Puckett

CF

41.6

11

Vada Pinson

CF

41.5

12

Jose Cruz Sr

LF

41.2

13

Mark Teixeira

1B

41.2

14

Fred McGriff

1B

41.1

15

Dale Murphy

CF

41.0

16

Bernie Williams

CF

40.8

17

David Ortiz

DH

40.7

18

Brian Giles

LF

40.6

19

Fred Lynn

CF

40.5

20

David Wright

3B

40.5

With the aspects that are staying the same covered, let’s get to the changes. To begin tweaking the list, we’ll start with the overall introduction to the Weighted WAR system. The primary concept covered here (weighting a player’s best season at 100%, second-best at 95%, and so on) remains unchanged. But the second stipulation mentioned in that post was that I decided to use Baseball Reference WAR (bWAR) in the evaluations. There are a number of other WAR options out there; these alternatives are conceptually similar, but don’t always agree on the final numbers. To compensate for cases in which bWAR has aberrant results, my HoM ballot will also factor in Fangraphs WAR (fWAR), which also covers all seasons back to 1871, as well as WAR 2.0 from Baseball Projection, which currently goes back to 1908 (pending further Retrosheet releases). I’m weighting bWAR at 50% and fWAR and WAR 2.0 at 25% each. (For the sake of both computational ease and my own sanity, adjustments are calculated based on comparisons in total WAR rather than re-running the Weighted WAR calculation with alternate seasonal values for hundreds of players.) Adjusting for the two other systems, let’s update the top 20 unelected position players and look at the differences:

Rank

Player

Position

WtWAR

Diff

1

John Olerud

1B

43.4

-0.5

2

Ron Cey

3B

43.1

+1.4

3

Buster Posey

C

42.4

+5.4

4

Jason Giambi

1B

42.0

-0.5

5

Cesar Cedeno

CF

41.7

-0.5

6

Robin Ventura

3B

41.5

-1.1

7

Willie Davis

CF

41.3

-1.1

8

Chet Lemon

CF

41.3

-2.4

9

Tony Perez

1B

41.3

+1.2

10

Jose Cruz Sr

LF

41.0

-0.3

11

David Wright

3B

40.8

+0.4

12

Fred McGriff

1B

40.5

-0.6

13

Kirby Puckett

CF

40.4

-1.2

14

Brian Giles

LF

40.2

-0.4

15

Ian Kinsler

2B

40.2

-2.0

16

Vada Pinson

CF

39.9

-1.6

17

Luis Gonzalez

LF

39.7

+1.1

18

Dale Murphy

CF

39.5

-1.5

19

Jim Rice

LF

39.4

+0.2

20

Mark Teixeira

1B

39.3

-1.9

That’s a good amount of shifting, even at the top of the list. #1 is still the same, and 16 of the original top 20 are still in the group somewhere. But the original #3 drops out, and the new #3 wasn’t listed before. Dustin Pedroia takes a hit from the alternative defensive evaluations (as do Bernie Williams and Fred Lynn).

Buster Posey, meanwhile, is representative of the most important difference between bWAR and our other two systems: the handling of catcher defense. For current-day catchers, Fangraphs accounts for pitch framing, which bWAR ignores. WAR 2.0, meanwhile, appears to implement a more aggressive evaluation of fielding for older catchers than either of the other two systems, resulting in a wider range of results. The outcome for most longtime catchers is a significant bump in score from this adjustment. For example, Russell Martin gains 4.4 Weighted WAR, Brian McCann 6.2, and Mike Scioscia 4.5. (Note that “most catchers” does not mean “all catchers;” Jorge Posada drops by 1.8, and Wally Schang by 2.6.)

That brings us to our second topic. As I mentioned in the original series, baseline Weighted WAR does not make specific adjustments for which position someone primarily plays; the player’s entire career is evaluated and I group them by position as a way to form conveniently-sized lists for ranking purposes. When compiling an overall list, as is required to assemble an HoM ballot, this becomes dicier.

The specific issue is catchers. Squatting behind the plate every day is inherently more difficult than playing any other position (apart from pitcher, of course); as such, catchers have durability issues both within single seasons and over the course of their careers. In 2026, five different players appeared at second base 140 or more times; nobody has played 140 games at catcher since Yadier Molina in 2016.

The results of this are obvious in any examination of all-time rankings. As stated in the original catcher rankings post, the top 100 catchers have significantly lower scores than the same group at any other position. The #50 catcher through 2025 (Mike Scioscia) would not make the top 100 in center field; the #75 catcher (Charles Zimmer) would fall short at every other position except second base, where he would rank at exactly #100. The overall position player top 100 through 2025 includes a mere three catchers; the fewest entrants at any other position (DH excluded) is left field, with eight. All the other positions are in double digits. The positional disparity is reduced by accounting for the other WAR systems, but is not eliminated.

One could reasonably argue that there is no injustice inherent in having fewer catchers in the HoM; if they’re not as productive as the other players on the ballot, shouldn’t the voting acknowledge that? Why should they get special treatment just because their position has some extra difficulties? After all, it’s not like you wouldn’t have any catchers selected; Weighted WAR’s top 200 position player list (a non-absurd approximate HoM cutoff) includes 11 of them.

I think there are two reasonable counterpoints to this argument. The first is based in how WAR accounts for position, which is by taking players who appear at multiple positions and comparing their defensive performance at each one. An average shortstop will usually be an above-average second or third baseman; an average left fielder will usually be a below-average center fielder.

This is generally a reasonable method… until you get to catchers. The responsibilities of second basemen and shortstops have significant skill overlap: field the grounder, throw it to first, turn the occasional double play, cover second on steal attempts, and so on. The same is true of the outfield spots. Catcher, however, is a completely different beast. The skills involved in working behind the plate have no real analog anywhere else on the diamond. As such, catchers require years of specialized training to have even a chance at holding down the position in the majors. A team may use an infielder in the outfield in a pinch; it’s even reasonably common for infielders to move to the outfield permanently (Mookie Betts, Ian Happ, and Fernando Tatis Jr. have all done this in recent memory). It is all but unheard of for an established major leaguer to move from another position to catcher in anything other than a dire emergency. As such, any attempt to assess catcher value by using catchers who also play other positions will trip over the enormously high skill floor that is required to station someone behind the plate in the majors at all.

Second, and more simply, shortchanging catchers is just distasteful to me. The arguments I’ve seen in favor sometimes compare catchers to relief pitchers or DHs, who don’t have equal representation with starting pitchers or first basemen. But catcher isn’t analogous to those positions, because it has existed in a prominent capacity throughout baseball history, rather than being either newly introduced or more heavily emphasized just a few decades ago. I think it’s worth giving them enough of a push to bring them roughly on par with other positions.

How much is that? Accounting for the aforementioned boost that catchers receive from the other WAR systems, an additional increase of 15% for catcher work appears to do the trick. Note that this bonus is only applied to the extent that the player actually spends time at catcher within each individual season, with Weighted WAR being recalculated using the adjusted values. Below are the career catcher adjustments for a few prominent backstops (that is, the ratio of each player’s catcher-adjusted Weighted WAR to his original WWAR total):

Player

CAdj

Ivan Rodriguez

1.15

Gary Carter

1.14

Buster Posey

1.12

Joe Mauer

1.10

Joe Torre

1.08

Craig Biggio

1.02

Rodriguez and Carter were almost exclusively deployed behind the plate. Mauer changed positions mid-career, while Posey was primarily a catcher for his whole career but often played first base on his rest days. Torre mixed both of these options, splitting time between catcher and first base early on before moving to first and third full-time in later seasons. Biggio, meanwhile, caught for only a few years before spending the bulk of his career (and all of his best years) at second base.

The catcher adjustment obviously leaves most of the original top 20 alone, since only one of them spent any significant time at the position. It does, however, add a couple of new faces, and provides a notable change at the top of the list:

Rank

Player

Position

WtWAR

Diff

1

Buster Posey

C

47.5

+5.1

2

John Olerud

1B

43.4

 

3

Ron Cey

3B

43.1

 

4

Jason Giambi

1B

42.0

 

5

Cesar Cedeno

CF

41.7

 

6

Robin Ventura

3B

41.5

 

7

Willie Davis

CF

41.3

 

8

Chet Lemon

CF

41.3

 

9

Tony Perez

1B

41.3

 

10

Jose Cruz Sr

LF

41.0

 

11

Gene Tenace

C

40.9

+3.3

12

David Wright

3B

40.8

 

13

Fred McGriff

1B

40.5

 

14

Kirby Puckett

CF

40.4

 

15

Brian Giles

LF

40.2

 

16

Ian Kinsler

2B

40.2

 

17

Vada Pinson

CF

39.9

 

18

Luis Gonzalez

LF

39.7

 

19

Russell Martin

C

39.5

+5.0

20

Dale Murphy

CF

39.5

 

Nice bump there for Buster Posey, and we see Gene Tenace and Russell Martin join the list as well. Tenace, like Torre, spent a good deal of time at other positions; his catcher adjustment is 1.09, compared to Posey’s 1.12 and Martin’s 1.15. But it’s enough to position him quite favorably here.

Those two adjustments probably have the most significant effects on the current ballot – but they aren’t the only ones we’ll be making. Next time, we’ll cover a few more tweaks, including war credit and postseason play.

No comments:

Post a Comment